Among 25 major treasury firms that hold cryptocurrencies as financial assets, 24 have market capitalisations below the value of the cryptocurrencies they hold, according to compiled data. CoinPost, a blockchain media outlet, reported on Nov. 18 that the result came from Blockworks data.
Bitcoin has fallen about 14 percent over the past week. Over the same period, shares of bitcoin-holding companies Strategy and Strive also fell more than 15 percent.
Treasury firms have raised funds by issuing new shares when their market capitalisations were higher than the value of the cryptocurrencies they hold, and have used the proceeds to buy more cryptocurrencies. The indicator showing this gap is mNAV. When a company’s value exceeds the market value of its crypto holdings, it has room for additional issuance, but a reading below 1 means the market values the company below its assets.
In that case, issuing new shares can dilute the equity value of existing shareholders more. Bloomberg pointed out that companies that have entered this valuation range are being pressed to choose between waiting for a price recovery and selling holdings to return funds to shareholders.
A report DWF Ventures released in September showed a similar trend. Among the top 20 firms by assets under management, only 4 had mNAV readings above 1. While the basis of calculation differs, Blockworks' latest figures also showed that only 1 firm received a valuation above the value of its holdings.
Strategy and Metaplanet are also set to be excluded from MSCI indexes. MSCI decided in its regular November review to remove Strategy from the MSCI U.S. index and Metaplanet from the MSCI Japan small-cap index at the close of trading on Nov. 30. Index-tracking funds must sell stocks removed from an index.
Blofin Research said Strategy’s share premium could narrow further if demand from passive funds declines. That has raised the possibility that the pace of additional purchases through new share issuance could also slow. Blofin Research added that the move is the first case in which MSCI applied a new “non-operating company” criterion adopted in October, and it does not affect continued listing or require the sale of bitcoin holdings.