A bitcoin wallet with no transactions for more than 15 years moved 75 BTC. With a $250 billion lawsuit under way arguing dormant bitcoin wallets should be treated as lost property, the transfer is being cited as a case showing the owner may still be managing the assets.
Blockchain outlet U.Today reported on Nov. 17 that a bitcoin address with no transaction record since 2011 made its first transfer of 75 BTC that day. The address is one of the wallets listed among defendants in a large lawsuit over ownership of dormant bitcoin wallets pending at the New York State Supreme Court.
The address first received bitcoin on Feb. 8, 2011, and then did not move for about 15 years and 8 months. It later sent funds to an external address for the first time at block height 976,209 on Nov. 17. Galaxy Research put the value of the 75 BTC at about $4.87 million, based on the current price.
At the time, bitcoin traded at about $0.90 each. That means holdings worth about $67.5 grew to about $4.87 million over about 15 years. The fee paid on the transaction was only 399 satoshis.
The address is classified in on-chain databases as "Noah Doe #3409". It is among the addresses targeted by a lawsuit in which anonymous plaintiffs ask the court to recognise long-inactive bitcoin wallets as lost. Galaxy Research said other addresses on the same defendant list have also moved bitcoin in 2026.
The lawsuit began when an anonymous plaintiff, "Noah Doe", and 2 companies claimed ownership of 39,069 bitcoin wallets with no transactions for more than 5 years. The plaintiffs argue the wallets hold about 3.8 million BTC, worth about $250 billion at current prices.
The plaintiffs cite provisions on lost items under Article 7-B of New York State personal property law as the basis for the lawsuit. They argue each bitcoin address should be valued at less than $10 and that the waiting period for the return of such lost items is 1 year.
They said they used an algorithm to find long-inactive wallets, saved the address information on USB flash drives and submitted it to the New York Police Department. They also claimed they notified wallet owners through blockchain microtransactions and OP_RETURN messages. The approach is linked to the "dusting" technique, which delivers messages to specific addresses by sending small amounts of cryptocurrency.
The lawsuit has faced difficulties as repeated motions to dismiss and court opinion filings continue. At a hearing on Sept. 8 last year, the Bitcoin Policy Institute asked to intervene on the defendants' side, and the Digital Chamber also applied to submit a court opinion.
Galaxy Research characterised the case as an attempt by anonymous plaintiffs to claim legal rights to Satoshi Nakamoto's bitcoin. Galaxy Research's Will Owens (윌 오언스), who attended the hearing, said the Digital Chamber's arguments were well organised and the judge appeared largely to agree with that reasoning.
Opponents point out that New York's laws on lost property were designed on the premise of tangible assets that can be physically picked up and handed to a custodian. They argue it is difficult for a third party without a private key to claim ownership of a wallet based only on blockchain transaction records.
Alex Thorn (알렉스 손), head of research at Galaxy Research, has previously pointed out that the law includes protections for legal ownership against "Noah Doe"-style dormant wallet attacks.
The 75 BTC transfer is expected to add a new variable to the debate over whether long inactivity alone allows bitcoin to be treated as lost property. That is because it supports the possibility that the owner held the private key and chose not to move the assets for a long time.
Some wallets included in the lawsuit have also resumed transactions, which could bolster the argument that dormancy and loss of ownership are not the same. Still, the transaction alone does not determine ownership of the remaining wallets or the direction of the lawsuit. How the court will judge ownership of long-unused bitcoin remains a key issue.