Concerns have been raised that Ethereum's next upgrade, dubbed 'Glamsterdam', could affect existing smart contracts. Developers are reviewing whether to adopt a scalability proposal that would sharply raise the per-block gas limit, after warnings it could change operating conditions for some contracts.
On Nov. 17 local time, blockchain outlet Decrypt reported that Ethereum developers are discussing whether to keep EIP-8037 and EIP-8038 in Glamsterdam or adjust the upgrade timeline by excluding some proposals.
The two proposals would expand Ethereum's per-block gas limit to as high as 200 million from the current 60 million. The aim is to increase network throughput and lower user transaction costs while managing growth in state data, using a limit about 3.3 times higher.
Concerns have emerged that as the gas limit is expanded, some smart contracts designed to rely on immutable conditions in the existing protocol could face unexpected problems in the changed environment.
Ethereum Foundation developer Marius van der Wijden (마리우스 판데르베이던), who took part in the scaling work, pointed out at a core developers meeting that multiple contracts rely on immutable conditions in the protocol that would be modified by EIP-8037 and EIP-8038.
The scope of the impact was confirmed late in development. ChainSecurity and Dedaub found about 200 types of contracts that could be affected through artificial intelligence-based audits. Many were classified as issues related to higher gas costs rather than the new operating method itself.
Van der Wijden estimated that about 10,000 to 15,000 smart contracts could be affected. That would be part of about 90 million contracts on Ethereum overall. He estimated that for contracts where the upgrade has not yet been confirmed, the amount of assets affected would be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Developers argued that the scale of the impact alone makes it hard to judge the issue. Jango, a Juicebox protocol developer, claimed the change could weaken composability, a core value of Ethereum, and undermine the trust of developers trying to build immutable protocols. A Uniswap developer also said EIP-8037 needs to be reviewed.
The Ethereum Foundation has previously delayed the Glamsterdam testnet fork schedule due to gas-related security issues. The meeting also failed to reach a final conclusion, and the discussion moved to a follow-up execution layer meeting.
A possible schedule delay is also a factor. Some developers predicted that excluding the proposals could delay not only Glamsterdam but also the subsequent roadmap leading to quantum-computer security by about 4 to 6 months.
Van der Wijden explained that external guidance schedules were also delayed due to an organizational overhaul and budget cuts at the Ethereum Foundation. He also said he is under significant pressure as the last scalability lead remaining at the foundation.
Glamsterdam has ultimately emerged as a key issue over how much it can boost network scalability while maintaining compatibility with existing smart contracts. The upgrade's direction and schedule are expected to vary depending on whether developers push ahead with the gas limit expansion plan as is or make adjustments to reduce the ecosystem's shock.