South Korean game companies posted operating profit in the third quarter but recorded net losses due to exchange-rate swings and worsening valuation gains and losses on financial products, the data showed.
A review on Nov. 18 of third-quarter results releases and quarterly reports from major game companies showed Krafton, Shift Up and Neowiz posted operating profit but reported net losses. Pearl Abyss, meanwhile, recorded a pretax loss as financial losses outweighed operating profit, but ended with a net profit.
Operating profit is profit earned from core operations such as game sales and services. Final net profit, however, also reflects foreign exchange gains and losses from currency fluctuations, gains and losses from valuing financial products, and corporate taxes. In the third quarter, foreign-currency-related gains and losses deteriorated, widening the gap between the two measures.
OPERATING PROFIT OF 225 BILLION WON BUT NET LOSS; CORE BUSINESS AND FINAL RESULTS DIVERGE
Krafton showed the biggest gap between operating profit and net profit or loss. Krafton posted third-quarter revenue of 971.4 billion won and operating profit of 225.0 billion won, but ended with a net loss of 68.4 billion won. The difference between operating profit and net results was 293.4 billion won.
Krafton said it incurred 305.8 billion won in non-operating losses, including foreign-currency-related losses stemming from a weaker dollar. It posted cumulative revenue of 3.63 trillion won and operating profit of 1.20 trillion won through the third quarter, marking its highest-ever results for the period, but in the quarter non-operating losses exceeded profit earned from its game business.
Shift Up also posted operating profit, but ended the quarter in the red. It reported third-quarter operating revenue of 46.2 billion won and operating profit of 20.7 billion won for an operating margin of 44.8 percent, but its net loss for the period reached 25.5 billion won. It maintained operating profit despite a sales decline for "Goddess of Victory: Nikke" and "Stellar Blade", but failed to offset losses in non-operating items.
Shift Up's third-quarter non-operating loss was about 53.7 billion won. Its quarterly report showed foreign exchange losses of about 9.4 billion won and foreign currency translation losses of about 12.4 billion won. Foreign exchange losses arise from exchange-rate differences during processes such as settling foreign-currency transactions, while foreign currency translation losses occur when foreign-currency assets or liabilities are recalculated at the exchange rate at the time of closing. Gains and losses from valuing and disposing of financial products and gains and losses from derivatives transactions were also reflected, resulting in a large loss across the non-operating segment.
Neowiz improved operating performance from the previous quarter but ended with a loss. Third-quarter revenue was 110.5 billion won and operating profit was 9.6 billion won, up 8.3 percent and 20.8 percent, respectively, from the previous quarter. Net profit or loss for the period, however, was a loss of 10.3 billion won.
Neowiz's non-operating loss was about 24.0 billion won. Financial income recorded a negative figure of about 3.8 billion won, while financial costs reached about 22.6 billion won. The company cited valuation and translation losses on foreign-currency financial assets due to a stronger won as the main reason. It posted a pretax loss of about 14.4 billion won, but corporate tax income of about 4.1 billion won was reflected, reducing the final net loss to 10.3 billion won.
PRETAX LOSS ON FINANCIAL LOSSES; PEARL ABYSS POSTS NET PROFIT ON CORPORATE TAX EFFECT
Pearl Abyss, unlike the other three companies, posted a net profit despite a pretax loss. It reported third-quarter revenue of 101.5 billion won and operating profit of 20.7 billion won, but a loss of about 45.3 billion won in financial gains and losses pushed pretax profit or loss to a loss of 25.1 billion won.
Pearl Abyss said foreign exchange losses and valuation losses on foreign-currency assets expanded as the won-dollar exchange rate fell due to a stronger won. Total financial gains and losses swung to a loss of about 45.3 billion won from a profit of about 12.2 billion won in the previous quarter.
For Pearl Abyss, which has an overseas sales share of 86 percent, exchange-rate moves also affected game sales. It sold about 680,000 copies of "Crimson Desert" in the third quarter, but its average selling price was about 59,000 won, down 4,000 won from 63,000 won in the previous quarter. The company said translation effects from a stronger won and discounted sales both had an impact.
Pearl Abyss, however, posted a net profit of 10.8 billion won despite a pretax loss of 25.1 billion won. Corporate tax income of about 35.9 billion won was reflected, turning the final result positive.
Accounting treatment related to corporate tax influenced Pearl Abyss' final profit. The company reversed some of the corporate tax expense it had reflected through the first half, and judged that valuation losses at its subsidiary PAI, which is being liquidated, could be used to reduce taxes in the future.
As a result, it recognised deferred tax assets of 28.6 billion won, reflecting expected future tax savings as an accounting asset. This does not mean cash actually flowed in. With the reversal of some first-half corporate tax expense and recognition of deferred tax assets reflected, Pearl Abyss posted a final net profit despite a pretax loss.
A 10 PERCENT DROP IN THE EXCHANGE RATE CUTS PRETAX PROFIT BY 20.5 BILLION WON; FOREIGN-CURRENCY ASSET STRUCTURE IS A VARIABLE
Even with the same currency move, the effect on profit and loss differs by company. Selling many games overseas does not necessarily lead to large foreign exchange losses. Actual gains and losses vary depending on the scale of a company's foreign-currency assets and liabilities and the composition of its financial products.
Shift Up's quarterly report shows these differences. As of end-September, Shift Up's dollar-denominated monetary assets stood at about 215.8 billion won, while dollar liabilities were about 11.2 billion won. Subtracting liabilities from assets yields about 204.6 billion won, a structure in which the won-converted amount falls when the dollar weakens and translation gains can arise when the dollar strengthens.
Shift Up disclosed that, with other conditions unchanged, a 10 percent fall in the won-dollar exchange rate would reduce pretax profit by about 20.5 billion won. That is similar in size to its third-quarter operating profit of 20.7 billion won. It means the potential impact of currency swings on profit or loss can be comparable to quarterly operating profit.
This, however, is an analysis that assumes the exchange rate moves by a certain amount based on foreign-currency assets and liabilities as of end-September. It does not mean a loss of 20.5 billion won actually occurred in the third quarter due to the exchange-rate decline.
Foreign currency translation losses can also arise when the exchange rate at the closing date is applied, meaning they can differ from actual cash outflows. The gap between operating profit and final net results also reflects not only foreign exchange losses but also valuation gains and losses on financial products and corporate taxes.
An industry official said, "If overseas sales by game companies increase, foreign-currency-related assets and transactions can also expand, but the impact of exchange-rate changes on results differs depending on each company's financial structure." The official said, "Especially in cases like this where operating profit and net profit diverge significantly, there is a need to distinguish and review not only foreign exchange gains and losses but also valuation gains and losses on financial products and the effects of corporate tax."