Kakao Future Initiative Center head Kim Beom-su (김범수), who was put on trial on charges of manipulating share prices during the acquisition of SM Entertainment, was acquitted on appeal following a first-instance not guilty verdict.
The court maintained its view that the fact Kakao's large on-exchange purchases affected the price alone made it difficult to recognise an intent to manipulate and a collusive relationship. Kakao, which is set to undergo a corporate spin-off next year, has also reduced some management uncertainty stemming from legal risk surrounding Kim.
The Seoul High Court's Criminal Division 4-1 on Thursday found Kim not guilty, the same as the first trial, on charges of violating the Capital Markets Act. Bae Jae-hyun, a former Kakao investment chief who was indicted together, was also found not guilty.
Kim and others were indicted on charges of manipulating SM's share price in February 2023, as Kakao competed with Hybe over management control of SM Entertainment. Prosecutors alleged they kept the share price above Hybe's tender offer price of 120,000 won per share to disrupt the tender offer. Prosecutors again sought a 15-year prison term for Kim at the appeal trial and asked the court to overturn the first-instance acquittal.
"It is not possible to punish all purchases based only on price impact"
The appeal court said that even if Kakao's on-exchange purchases actually affected SM's share price, it could not immediately be seen as price manipulation.
It said all trades can affect prices to varying degrees, and punishing all purchases simply because on-exchange buying influenced the price could excessively broaden the scope of punishment.
It also found that the evidence submitted by prosecutors did not prove that Kim and others had the purpose of manipulating or stabilising the price through artificial intervention, or that the defendants colluded in doing so.
That was in line with the first-instance ruling. The first trial court also held it could not recognise price manipulation based only on the fact Kakao carried out large-scale on-exchange purchases during Hybe's tender offer period and affected SM's share price.
At the time, the court said Kakao's purchase orders differed from manipulation-type orders when considering factors such as time intervals and order patterns. It also said it was difficult to conclude there was a purpose to artificially fix SM's share price above a normal market price.
Prosecutors appealed, arguing that messages and call records involving Kakao officials and the share purchasing process showed Kakao sought to keep SM's share price above a certain level to block Hybe's tender offer and that the defendants colluded in advance.
Prosecutors also argued on appeal that the first trial failed to properly assess multiple pieces of evidence consistent with the alleged crime, raising claims of factual error and misunderstanding of legal principles. The appeal court, however, also said the evidence presented made it difficult to recognise the purpose of price manipulation and collusion, and upheld the first-instance acquittal.
Kim has also argued throughout the trial that he neither ordered nor colluded in price manipulation. In his final statement at the sentencing hearing, he denied the charges, saying no specific evidence of collusion had been presented on when, where and to whom he allegedly gave instructions to manipulate prices.
He also said he opposed buying additional SM shares during the tender offer period to engage in a stake battle with Hybe, and maintained that the issue should be resolved through negotiations.
Kakao, ahead of spin-off, sees some easing of management uncertainty
With Kim acquitted on appeal, uncertainty surrounding major management issues, including Kakao's planned corporate spin-off, is also expected to ease somewhat.
Kakao is pushing ahead with a corporate spin-off that will split the company into KakaoAI and KakaoX. KakaoAI will focus on AI and platform businesses based on KakaoTalk, while KakaoX will centre on key affiliates and investment businesses to find new growth engines. Kakao plans to build decision-making and capital allocation systems tailored to each business to accelerate growth at both companies.
Ahead of the spin-off, Kakao is operating a task force involving key departments such as technology, finance and human resources. It is also continuing to explain the purpose of the split and growth strategy to domestic and overseas investors and shareholders.
Kakao plans to obtain approval for the split at an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders on Jan. 15 next year and complete the split on Feb. 1. The change of listing for KakaoX and relisting for KakaoAI are scheduled for Feb. 25. Detailed schedules may change depending on consultations with relevant agencies.
Kim's criminal trial has been one factor increasing management uncertainty as Kakao pushes ahead with the spin-off and business restructuring. With the acquittal upheld on appeal following the first trial, the related burden will be further reduced.
The legal process is not yet fully concluded. If prosecutors appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court, the court will still have to decide.