Bitmine (Shutterstock photo)

An estimate has been published that puts Ethereum treasury firm Bitmine’s unrealised valuation loss at about $8.83 billion. Critics say it is hard to treat this as the company’s actual valuation loss because the holding amount and the average purchase price used in the calculation are based on different reference dates.

On Nov. 15, blockchain outlet CryptoSlate reported that Flood, a trader who uses the X (formerly Twitter) account ThinkingUSD (@ThinkingUSD), shared an image of a dashboard on Nov. 13 showing an estimate of Bitmine’s valuation loss. He criticised Ethereum as a "contender" for the "worst asset of all time" and cited Bitmine’s holdings as an example.

The image shows Ethereum holdings of 6,070,092 and an average purchase price of $3,380. Based on those figures, the total acquisition cost was presented as about $20.52 billion, and the market value of the holdings as about $11.69 billion. The resulting valuation loss was estimated at about $8.83 billion, with a loss rate of about 43 percent.

The key issue is the reference date of the data used in the calculation. The holdings figure matches the amount Bitmine disclosed in November, but the average purchase price is shown as of late August. Bitmine’s holdings at the end of August were 5,901,837, and as the holdings increased afterward, the overall average purchase price could also change depending on the price of the additional purchases.

Multiplying the November holdings by the August average purchase price broadly matches the total acquisition cost shown on the dashboard. That calculation does not confirm the dashboard’s internal methodology or the actual acquisition cost of the increased holdings. Bitmine did not present an updated total acquisition cost in its November disclosure.

The reference date for the valuation is also unclear. The Ethereum price Bitmine presented when it announced its November holdings was also a price used to calculate market value at the time and is distinct from the company’s average purchase price. The accuracy of the estimated loss can be assessed only after confirming the respective baselines for acquisition cost and market value.

The figures are also an estimate of unrealised loss calculated from the difference between an assumed acquisition cost and market value, not a loss realised through asset sales. They should also be distinguished from the latest loss amount officially announced by the company or profit and loss for an accounting year. Judging the company’s actual investment performance based only on a large loss figure can confuse numbers of different nature.

To determine the scale of the loss more accurately, Bitmine’s latest total acquisition cost and the valuation of its holdings at the same point in time would be needed. Until that baseline is confirmed through additional disclosures, the $8.83 billion figure should be viewed as an external estimate applying a past average purchase price. The core of the controversy is not the loss amount itself, but how accurately a calculation combining data from different points in time reflects actual holdings.

Arguably Ethereum is one of the worst things to happen to humanity. The amount of capital lost to hacks, human capital lost due to developing with suboptimal tooling and retail capital destroyed from longing the asset makes it a contender for the worst asset of all time. https://t.co/1BLMEOQ6QD

Keyword

#Ethereum #Bitmine #CryptoSlate #X #ThinkingUSD
Copyright © DigitalToday. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution are prohibited.