Google plans to disable Search as well if schools turn off AI features starting next year. [Photo: Shutterstock]

Major U.S. school districts are considering alternatives to Google Search. Google has said schools that disable artificial intelligence (AI) features will also be unable to use its search service.

IT outlet The Verge reported on Nov. 18 that schools in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are reviewing services that could replace Google Search. Google plans to block access to Google Search from early next year if schools turn off all Gemini-based AI features. Chris Phillips (크리스 필립스), a vice president at Google’s education unit, said, "Search and AI are deeply integrated," adding that schools that disable AI features will not be able to use the search service.

U.S. politicians and education authorities pushed back strongly. New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani (조란 맘다니) and Senator Bernie Sanders (버니 샌더스) criticised Google’s move as "extortion." Mamdani previously announced a policy to delay the use of generative AI in classrooms for 1 year for students from 2-K, a pre-kindergarten programme, through grade 8.

New York City schools Chancellor Kamar H. Samuels (카마르 H. 사무엘스) said the city would consider other search services if Google does not change its position. Chicago Public Schools has also been reported as having told Google it would look for another search solution if it cannot provide search services without AI features. Schools in the Los Angeles area have also begun reviewing alternatives.

Google said it will adjust how it runs services to reflect concerns from the education field. Google spokesperson Laura Breen (로라 브린) said she agreed with parents and teachers who are concerned that students could use AI to skip parts of the learning process, adding that the goal is to help students learn.

Google has been running a pilot of a "guided learning" feature on its search service since this month. The feature helps students solve problems step by step rather than providing immediate answers to complex questions. From next year, Google plans to change its controls so schools can choose among services such as the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search, and to keep them disabled by default until a school turns them on.

Concerns in education have focused on AI’s impact on students’ critical thinking and academic performance. Some studies have found lower test scores among students who use AI, and concerns have also been raised about mental health issues linked to forming relationships with chatbots from a young age.

Still, it is not easy for schools to leave the Google ecosystem completely. Google services such as Google Classroom and Chromebooks are widely adopted in U.S. schools. The controversy shows Google’s influence on school technology infrastructure, along with conflict over the scope of AI use in education.

Keyword

#Google #Google Search #Gemini #New York #Chicago Public Schools
Copyright © DigitalToday. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution are prohibited.