As shares of Hanpass, which listed this year, fall, attention is turning to how fintech companies pursuing IPOs will be valued. [Photo: ChatGPT]

[DigitalToday reporter Ji-young Lee] Shares of cross-border remittance fintech Hanpass, which entered the KOSDAQ market in March, have fallen more than 80 percent from the IPO price, drawing attention to how this may affect later fintech initial public offerings. In the IPO market, fintech companies including E9Pay and Banksalad are proceeding with listing procedures. As Hanpass struggles with weak performance and a share-price drop after listing, attention is focused on how those companies will be valued.

On the 13th, Hanpass shares closed at 3,510 won on the KOSDAQ. That was down 81.5 percent from the IPO price of 19,000 won at its March 25 listing.

Hanpass drew strong investor interest early in its listing process. In demand forecasting for institutional investors, it recorded a competition ratio of 1,172 to 1 and set the IPO price at 19,000 won, the top end of the indicated range. The competition ratio for the retail subscription also reached 1,673 to 1.

On the first day of trading, the stock rose as high as 47,750 won intraday, more than 2.5 times the IPO price, but it did not sustain the rise. The closing price that day was down 92.6 percent from the intraday peak on the first trading day.

Alongside the weak share price, earnings also deteriorated. Hanpass' consolidated second-quarter revenue this year was about 14.4 billion won, down 15 percent from a year earlier. Operating loss came to about 3.2 billion won, turning to a deficit. The company listed after being recognized for growth potential based on overseas remittances and payment and daily financial services for foreigners, but securing profitability has remained a task since listing.

Hanpass is a fintech company that grew around its overseas remittance business. As of the first half of this year, its digital remittance business accounted for about 76.5 percent of total revenue. It is expanding into areas including mobile wallets and prepaid cards, but it still relies heavily on remittance fees and foreign-currency trading income. That makes it a key task whether higher remittance volumes translate into actual profitability improvement.

In connection with this, the overseas remittance industry has raised criticism that it is difficult to secure stable profits with only market growth and higher transaction volumes. Expansion of the foreign remittance market itself is positive, but intensifying competition for market share could increase pressure to cut fees, it said.

In particular, in a business structure where remittance fees and foreign-currency trading income make up a significant part of revenue, profitability could worsen even if transaction volumes increase if competition to cut fees intensifies to win customers. Observers say this is similar to cases involving virtual asset exchanges in that a fee-free policy to expand transaction volume does not necessarily lead to improved profits.

A fintech industry official said, "It is positive that the foreign remittance market is growing and the market is expanding, but whether it leads to actual service performance and improved profitability is a separate issue." The official added, "In a structure that relies heavily on remittance fees for profits, if fees are lowered to increase market share, profitability could worsen."

The official added, "As Hanpass' share price has fallen sharply since listing, the vulnerability of its profit structure is being exposed." The official said, "Since it is difficult to secure sustainable profitability simply by increasing user numbers or remittance volumes, the profit structure will be an important variable in competition with E9Pay, which is preparing to list."

◆ E9Pay pushes listing with profitability in front; valuation draws attention

Hanpass' share-price trend is also becoming a noteworthy case for E9Pay, which is preparing to list in the same overseas remittance industry. E9Pay passed the Korea Exchange's preliminary review for a KOSDAQ listing on Oct. 15. Korea Investment & Securities is the lead underwriter, and the company plans to proceed with the offering process through steps including filing a securities registration statement and demand forecasting for institutional investors.

Like Hanpass, E9Pay has overseas remittances as its main business, but it shows differences in performance. Last year it posted revenue of 64.7 billion won, operating profit of 23.7 billion won and net profit of 19.6 billion won, with an operating margin of 36.7 percent.

It also posted revenue of 38.25 billion won and operating profit of 11.78 billion won in the first half of this year. The first-half operating margin was 30.8 percent.

E9Pay is highlighting as strengths a two-way remittance structure that operates both outward remittances sent overseas and inward remittances received in South Korea, and a direct settlement network with global financial institutions. It says improved efficiency in fund operations through two-way remittances and reduced intermediary fees form the basis for securing profitability.

Hanpass' share-price drop after listing is one of the variables to be reviewed in E9Pay's valuation process. But while both companies share overseas remittances as a main business, differences in profit structure and results make it difficult to judge appropriate enterprise value based solely on share-price comparisons.

In particular, attention is focused on whether E9Pay will include Hanpass among peer companies for setting the IPO price, and how it will reflect profitability differences. Since peer stock prices and valuation multiples can affect the indicated offering price, it appears necessary to check the valuation rationale that will be included in the securities registration statement.

◆ Banksalad, OrangeSquare and others also pursue IPOs; profitability differentiation is key

Fintech companies are continuing to pursue IPOs. Banksalad, an asset management platform based on MyData, applied last month to the Korea Exchange for a preliminary review for a KOSDAQ listing. Mirae Asset Securities is the lead underwriter.

Banksalad is expanding its business based on asset management and brokerage of financial products. Last year, its separate revenue was 26.0 billion won, up 77 percent from a year earlier. But its adjusted EBITDA, excluding non-cash costs such as stock compensation expenses, posted a loss of 1.9 billion won. The deficit narrowed 74 percent from a year earlier. With revenue growth and a shrinking deficit, whether profitability improves will likely be a key factor in valuation.

OrangeSquare, which operates the payment and currency exchange platform "Wowpass" for foreigners, also applied on the 30th of last month for a preliminary review for a KOSDAQ listing. Korea Investment & Securities is the lead underwriter.

OrangeSquare provides currency exchange and prepaid card payment services for foreigners visiting South Korea. Its business structure differs from Hanpass and E9Pay, which focus on overseas remittances, but it shares a common foundation in the foreigner financial services market.

Affinitt, which provides financial services mainly in the Indian market, is also pursuing a KOSDAQ listing. It applied for a preliminary review in August, and Mirae Asset Securities and Hana Securities are serving as underwriters.

Affinitt posted revenue of 112.3 billion won and operating profit of 29.6 billion won in the first half of this year. That was up 45.8 percent and 79.4 percent, respectively, from a year earlier. With an operating margin of 26.4 percent, it is pursuing a listing after securing profitability.

As such, fintech companies pursuing IPOs differ across business areas including overseas remittances, asset management, payment services for foreigners and overseas financial platforms, and there are significant differences in performance as well. Accordingly, Hanpass' weak share price after its listing early this year is not expected to have a uniform impact on the valuation of later fintech companies, the report said.

Even so, the growth potential and profitability of fintech companies pursuing listings are expected to act as key variables in valuation. Beyond top-line growth, stable profit-generation capacity, earnings sustainability and the appropriateness of peer selection are expected to be considered important in the process of setting IPO prices.

Another fintech industry official said, "It is difficult to value a fintech company based only on one of growth potential or current profitability." The official added, "In addition to growth potential in the market and business competitiveness, it will be necessary to comprehensively consider the business structure and profit-generating capabilities that can connect these to sustainable profits."

The official added, "Companies preparing to list are also closely watching recent market conditions and other companies' share-price trends after listing." The official said, "But since an IPO should be prepared based on a company's fundamental competitiveness and business performance rather than short-term market sentiment, they should focus on strengthening their growth and profit base."

Keyword

#Hanpass #KOSDAQ #E9Pay #Banksalad #OrangeSquare
Copyright © DigitalToday. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution are prohibited.